Buy Tickets Sign Up for Starmail Account Log In
 

Need a domain name, click here for a free registration

Sep 27

Written by: Theatre Under The Stars
9/27/2012 10:55 AM

Hello again, readers!

In the past week several articles have surfaced on the importance of the arts within Houston.  It's reported in the Houston Business Journal, "that the local nonprofit arts and culture industry generates $977.7 million in annual economic activity in the greater Houston area."  That is an astounding amount of money!  What I saw lacking in many of the stories, if not all, was any kind of mention of musicals and companies like Theatre Under The Stars.

This made me wonder why the American musical is not seen as a culturally elite form of art.  In other words, why is musical theatre looked upon as the "poor man's" opera, ballet or symphony? 
I searched the internet to see if others have ever questioned this theory and sadly did not find much information.  Is this just a social issue we accept in the hierarchy of high-class art? One blogger, Ryan Bogner, wrote the following in his piece "Bound By Broadway: The State of the American Musical":

"...musical theater exists primarily in the commercial mode, the form is looked down upon by many theater makers and is considered to be more akin to the latest big-budget Hollywood romantic comedy than a worthy form of artistic expression. This might be partially attributed to the fact that the form is relatively young and has yet to reach a highbrow status (if you start counting at Oklahoma!, book musicals as we know them have only existed for seventy years). But I believe that musical theater has matured to a point where it will be difficult to grow any further until it begins to be treated with the same reverence and aesthetic scrutiny that we place upon plays." 

Perhaps the answer to my question really is because musical theatre is still the youngest of its art siblings aka the opera, ballet, and symphony.   Why do you think musical theatre is excluded as a “fine art” form and looked at primarily as only a commercial product? Why do you see and/or love musicals?

Until next time,
Thea

 

Tags:

3 comments so far...

Re: Why Aren’t Musicals Seen As A Culturally Elite Form of Art?

I think the lack of education on the part of those who put musicals down is the cause. I only recently was exposed to the world of theatre and it began with musical theatre and I have seen some great work from great actors/actresses. These men and women work their hearts, minds, and souls out to perform and they both have to know their written lines but also the words to the songs they sing and the movement and dance numbers. That is an extraordinary number of things to memorize and do.

Each time I go to a musical I actually analyze what is going on in the play--the expressions and interactions between performers. There are a lot of dynamics that go on and for someone who has only little experience in this world to be able to see this then those who are in the field should be able to see this. However sometimes these put downs are a sign of arrogance and wanting others to believe that their form of theatre is better than others. I think all forms of theatre contribute significantly to the world and should be appreciated as such. With no one form better than another but linked together as a way of helping humanity retain its touch with civilized culture.

By Jane Collins on   11/8/2012 10:58 AM

Re: Why Aren’t Musicals Seen As A Culturally Elite Form of Art?

Could it be the new plastic tumblers you're letting people taking into the theatre..........????

By Michael Bennett on   10/9/2012 3:12 PM

Re: Why Aren’t Musicals Seen As A Culturally Elite Form of Art?

I don't know why, but I do know that when I was helping my son check into different colleges, I was almost offended when one grad student on the other end of the phone told me that that university only had studies in legitimate theater, not musicals. That may be a common term for it, but I don't like that connotation.

By Peggy Price on   10/1/2012 4:37 PM

Your name:
Title:
Comment:
Security Code
Enter the code shown above in the box below
Add Comment    Cancel  

The views, conclusions, findings and opinions of the authors are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of Theatre Under The Stars or their employees. This blog is “family friendly” and comments which include offensive or inappropriate language, or considered by Theatre Under The Stars to be rude and offensive, will be edited or deleted.

 
Bookmark and Share